Liberty, liberty

“Man makes plans; God laughs.”

I woke up to the familiar tone of wondering what to do for the day: divine humour in the form of a deluge of thoughts. I love to think. The pleasure of the mind at work is impeccable, but it also is suffocating when it is brought about in this way. There are many ‘possibilities’ and ‘potentials’ for what is and what is to come. When I think of all of them: ennui. Nothing seems to be more disinteresting than uncovering the magic behind the day to day. Why then is there such a strong compulsion to keep doing so?

That might be one of the greatest ironies of the freedom of the human person: to use our very liberation to build our own prisons. Every time a bar falls away from the made-up jail cell, we put three more for fear of losing that which stands for our home but one in which we can never rest. We had locked ourselves up in the basements of our houses, acting out the illusion of waiting for the sentence that is never to come.

Yet maybe that is the point: perhaps life is more prison than home. Or that it is, as one of its many possibilities, all of which are equally good (or equally nothing). The pain of boredom might just be as delicious as the relief of celebration. After all, is not an overarching sense of uncertainty just as empty as that of a magic show where one explains the tricks behind every illusion?

I think about the morning and how thinking goes in the morning. I did not get to where I am with thought but thought is part of where I am. The illusion had been that thought caused of all of these—good and bad and nothing and everything. The truth is that I cannot really tell whether such is the case. But when I think of the cold metal of my cell, I feel the sting of the illusion. Once it no longer functions as support, it starts to become constriction.

These are not prison walls; this is my house and I can rebuild it as I want.

How do you proclaim to a prisoner that they are free? That they have always been free? That the cold metal bars were never real and they could have just walked through them from the start? One word and you will be responded with many: all the why’s and how’s and such and such. Endless questions’ endless thinking. What is it that would simply make them walk through the prison bars and experience what it is like to be on the other side?

It is impossible to market an experience of transformation. You cannot motivate another to change themselves. The philosopher L.A. Paul describes the dilemma as this: the person who had become a vampire will not be the same person who is choosing to be a vampire. The very means of existence for each differs. However, is it not the case that they are, essentially, one and the same person? The person after the decision is the same as the one who is making the decision who is also the same as the one who is yet to think of the decision.

But it also is the case that to become a vampire means to experience first not being one and then the change. How can one be something they already are?

Hence we have illusions. We sit at the centre of the basement believing ourselves to be imprisoned to make for the possibility of experiencing the process of becoming liberated. Part of which, perhaps, is that attempt to figure out how to break out of this whimsical jail cell, whether by thought or force. There is that belief that if we figure out the trick, we would be able to do magic.

Magic, however, is not simply about the seen created by the unseen; magic is that inexplicable dance between the two. Something is magical precisely because when we see it, we know that there are workings invisible to us, the spectator, that are going right under our noses. No matter how much we try to look, we should not be able to find.

But what else is there besides ‘magic’? What else is there besides trying to figure out potentials and possibilities?

The difference between the idol and the icon, according to Jean-Luc Marion, is the gaze with which we perceive. I think it might simply be that we believe there to be a difference between the two. Neither idolatry nor iconicity changes god, after all. Humans, however, are transformed—bread and wine become man, and man, something else?